When you go out on your own, you think about the tools, the clients and the cash flow. Very few people think about what happens if a job goes badly and someone comes after them personally. The way you set up your business decides whether a dispute stays with the business or ends up on your kitchen table. That’s why good business structure advice in Melbourne starts with one question: what are you trying to protect? It’s a question small business accountants see answered too late more often than you’d think. Fixing a structure later can also trigger tax, so a capital gains tax specialist will usually tell you it’s far cheaper to get it right from day one.
Sole traders: You are the business
As a sole trader, the law doesn’t separate you from your business. Your liability is unlimited, so business debts are personal debts.
Picture a tiler whose waterproofing fails and floods a downstairs unit. If the repair bill and legal costs go beyond his insurance, the claim can reach his savings, his ute and his share of the family home. In the worst case, it ends in personal bankruptcy.
A sole trader set-up is still a sensible, low-cost option for plenty of people. It just needs to sit alongside proper public liability and, for consultants, professional indemnity insurance.
Partnerships: Your mate’s mistakes are your mistakes
Under Victoria’s Partnership Act 1958, partners are generally jointly and severally liable for partnership debts. In plain English, a creditor can chase any one partner for the full amount.
Say two mates team up to start a restaurant and one of them signs a big supplier account without telling the other. If the business can’t pay, the supplier can go after whichever partner has more assets. A written partnership agreement helps settle things between you, but it won’t stop creditors.
Companies: A wall, not a fortress
A Pty Ltd company is a separate legal entity from you. It owns its assets, signs its contracts and carries its own debts. As a shareholder, you usually only risk what you’ve put in.
That’s why many contractors and consultants move to a company as they grow. The protection is real, but it has gaps, and that’s where you can get caught out. For example, using a small business accountant often means your personal PAYG instalments aren’t managed by them, although some do offer this as an optional, additional service.
Where the protection runs out
A company can do a lot to shield you, but it isn’t bulletproof. These are the three main ways business debts can still land on you personally, and most of them come down to what you sign and what you lodge.
Personal guarantees
Banks, landlords, equipment financiers and trade suppliers often ask directors to guarantee company debts personally. Once you sign, the company structure won’t protect you from that debt. Before you sign, read the guarantee, keep a list of every one you’ve given and ask whether it can be capped.
Director duties
The Corporations Act 2001 requires directors to act with care and diligence, in good faith and in the company’s best interests. Under section 588G, you can be personally liable for debts the company takes on while it’s insolvent.
The “safe harbour” rules give some protection to directors who are actively working on a better outcome, but only if conditions are met, such as keeping proper books and staying up to date with tax lodgements.
The risk is real in the trades. ASIC’s insolvency statistics regularly show construction as the industry with the most company insolvencies, at around a quarter of all cases in recent years.
Tax and super debts
Under the ATO’s director penalty regime, directors can be personally liable for a company’s unpaid PAYG withholding, GST and super guarantee charge. If these amounts aren’t reported within three months of the due date, most of your options for getting out of that liability disappear. Lodging on time, even when you can’t pay, is one of the simplest protections you have.
Trusts and the “Put it in her name” myth
A discretionary trust with a company as trustee can add another layer between your business and your personal assets. If an individual acts as trustee, though, that person can still be personally liable.
Then there’s the old habit of moving the house into a partner’s name. Under the Bankruptcy Act 1966, a trustee in bankruptcy can sometimes reverse transfers made to defeat creditors, but the timing matters a lot. Moving assets can also trigger stamp duty and capital gains tax, so talk to a capital gains tax specialist before you shift anything.
Getting business structure advice in Melbourne before it matters
Protecting your personal assets and your family doesn’t depend on one clever move. It comes from a structure that suits your risk, plus good habits that keep the protection working. The best time to get business structure advice in Melbourne is before you sign the big contract, hire your first worker, or buy that new ute. Experienced small business accountants can show you where your gaps are, and a capital gains tax specialist can make sure any restructure doesn’t come with a nasty tax bill.
Note: This article is general information only and isn’t legal, tax or financial advice. Laws and ATO rules change, so check the current position and get advice for your own situation.